• 0 Posts
  • 885 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: July 24th, 2023

help-circle

  • Indeed. Unfortunately in the age of abundant air travel and being able to do basically everything online, including remaining in contact with people, it’s not hard to just move out of the UK if you’re super wealthy.

    We absolutely can and should tax assets that can’t be moved out of the UK, though, like land. A multi-millionaire can move all kinds of things out of the country, but they cannot take their land with them. Land value would of course go down or stagnate, but I don’t personally see that as a bad thing.

    That said, even if you took all billionaire wealth in the UK (while somehow simultaneously preventing a crash in the value of those assets), it’d last months. It wouldn’t be a permanent solution. State spending is £1.2 trillion, a small amount of billionaires aren’t going to plug the gap for long.

    There’s no simple solution to the financial situation this country is in.

    E: I guess people don’t want solutions, they just want someone who agrees with them.














  • One of the few sensible comments I’ve seen in this community.

    The left is obsessed with splintering over the slightest little thing. Time and time again it feels like they’d rather be confined to the political wilderness but pat themselves on the back for feeling ideologically pure than accepting compromises but having a real shot at being in a position where they can make positive change.

    Bluntly, there has been a lot from the Green party over the years that I really don’t like. From being extremely into NIMBYism (even to the extent where they end up being against green energy developments), some policies (which have now been dropped) that went against gender equality, and some IMO insane and isolationist anti-NATO nonsense at a time when the world is becoming more hostile and militaristic (some of that has been dropped).

    But I’d vote for them in a heartbeat if the alternative is the Tory-Reform uniparty. It angers me somewhat that Corbyn and Sultana, alongside the Muslim independents they’ve allied with, are trying to make a new party that only further splits the vote and hands more power to their adversaries who’ve openly become a UK MAGA party. They could’ve joined the Greens and strengthened the left vote, but they instead chose to weaken it.



  • clamping down on protest

    What clamping down on protest? Charging violent thugs in the race riots last year? I wouldn’t count that. Protesting is different to rioting. Charging people for supporting a proscribed group? That’s fair enough. I’ve been to a number of pro Palestine protests, and nothing bad has happened. To the contrary, the government has been cutting ties with Israel and shifting towards Palestine.

    population tracking via government issued ID cards

    How? I don’t think a right to work check counts as tracking.

    implemented draconian internet crackdown laws

    Fair enough, the OSA is a bit crap. Unfortunately it has broad support, both from politicians and the public.

    and won’t shut up about immigration

    Like it or not, that’s what the electorate wants. And he’s here to govern the country, not just Labour supporters.

    What happened to all of the good policies

    Those have been getting implemented, but you don’t hear it in many headlines.

    You will never have a government you agree with on every issue.

    Even the government themselves will have to do things they don’t want to do, either for parliamentary, media, or electorate support, or things like fiscal reality. Unfortunate, but that’s the real world.


  • Politician massages the ego of the world’s most powerful toddler world leader, because it’s a proven effective strategy. More at 11.

    Anybody who has a memory beyond that of a goldfish would know that Starmer has been ramping up on domestic and European defence spending in light of Russia’s continued aggression, that our 6th Gen GCAP jet is progressing well (which doesn’t have US involvement), we’ve been signing defensive pacts with various European countries as well as a few in South America, plus Australia, and we declined to join the US and Israel on their strikes on Iran.

    The headline is clearly trying to bait readers into thinking we’re taking a subservient position to the US and letting them handle everything. Objective reality is that Starmer has been shifting away from the US for defence, while occasionally giving diplomatic lip service.

    I appreciate it’d look ‘based’ if Starmer called Trump a moron on Twitter, but it would do nothing other than damage us economically and diplomatically. I’m glad pragmatism is winning over populism in this case, tbh.



  • It is so frustrating to see Labour being compared to Tories. Frankly it just shows when someone hasn’t been looking at the news.

    • nationalising trains
    • (sort of) nationalising steel
    • nationalising a part of our energy sector
    • bringing the NHS back under direct public control
    • ending various tax-dodging loopholes, such as the IHT for farmers and non-dom taxes
    • windfall tax on energy companies
    • charging VAT on private schooling
    • expanding free childcare
    • restarting SureStart (albeit under a different name)
    • expanding free school meals
    • expanding school breakfast clubs
    • guaranteeing jobs for young people (announced this morning)
    • big increases to the minimum wage, especially for the youngest
    • expansion of workers rights
    • expansion of renters rights
    • big increase in infrastructure investment, particularly for renewables
    • actually engaging with France over surging illegal immigration rather than spending billions on a Rwanda plan that won’t work and would send people somewhere we know to be unsafe

    That’s just off the top of my head.

    Not agreeing with XYX Labour action is fine. You will never ever have a government you universally agree with. But to look at the current lot and say they’re the same as the Tories is simply uninformed.

    I can’t believe Reform have been having such an easy time pushing such a blatantly false narrative.